[1]Principia Cybernetica Web

                                The Homunculus problem

   Cartesian materialism is an attempt to keep the mechanistic metaphysics of
   Descartes while getting rid of the idea on an immaterial soul ([2]dualism). In
   this philosophy, the mind is seen as a (material) component of the body (e.g. the
   brain or some component of it) that interacts with the world via the senses and
   muscles. The philosopher Daniel Dennett has proposed the term "Cartesian theater"
   to summarize the picture that results when this idea is combined with the
   reflection-correspondence perspective: the mind somehow sits in a theater where
   the incoming perceptions are projected as images onto a screen; it looks at them,
   interprets them, and decides what to do; it sends its decisions as commands to
   the muscles for execution. In a more modern metaphor, we would describe the
   situation as if the mind acts as a control center for the body, the way an air
   traffic controller keeps track of the incoming planes on a radar screen,
   analyzing the situation, and issuing directions to the pilots. While this picture
   may seem more satisfying to a scientifically trained mind than Descartes' ghostly
   soul, it merely shifts the difficulty.

   The fundamental problem with the mind as control center is that it is equivalent
   to a homunculus (diminutive of the Latin "homo" = human being): a little person
   watching the theater inside our brain, and reasoning like an intelligent being in
   order to deal with the situation it observes. However, the point of the exercise
   was precisely to explain how a person reasons! We have explained the mind simply
   by postulating another, "smaller" mind (homunculus) within the mind.

   Such reasoning leads to an infinite regress. Indeed, to explain how the
   homunculus functions we must assume that it has a mind, which itself implies
   another homunculus inside it, which must contain yet another homunculus, and so
   on. It is as if we are opening a series of Russian dolls the one nested into the
   other one, without ever coming to the last one. Another way to illustrate the
   circularity of such reasoning would be to consider a recipe for making cake where
   one of the ingredients is cake: how can you ever prepare such a cake if you don't
   already know how to do it? To evade this paradox, we need to make a radical break
   with the way of thinking that produced it.

The need for a systems view

   To stop such an infinite regress, we need to posit a place where it ends: the
   component of our brain where consciousness resides and where rational decisions
   are made. But unless we go back to Cartesian [3]dualism, and postulate a
   mysterious, ungraspable soul, we will not find such a place where the outside
   world ends and the true mind begins. Indeed trying to pinpoint the place where
   decisions are made, we still come to the conclusion that that place must be able
   to perceive what is going on outside of itself, and therefore that it must have a
   seat in the theater, bringing us back to the homunculus reasoning.

   The attempt to situate the mind in a specific place or separate component is a
   remnant of reductionism, the philosophy that explains all phenomena by analyzing
   them into separate parts, and then determining the properties of the parts. We
   should understand the mind not as a collection of parts, but as a whole, which is
   distributed over many components. It is not located in any one of them, but in
   the network of their relations or interconnections. Different parts of cognitive
   processes take place in different parts of the network, but there is no single
   part where everything comes together, no "seat of the soul". We should also
   accept that there is no one-to-one [4]correspondence between mental and physical
   components: the mind as a whole stands in a complex relationship to the world as
   a whole. Mental components do not behave like static, independent objects. They
   are part of a dynamic network of relationships: a process. Such a holistic and
   dynamic perspective requires a new scientific worldview, which we can find in
   [5]evolutionary cybernetics.
     ____________________________________________________________________________

   [6]Copyright© 2007 Principia Cybernetica - [7]Referencing this page

   Author

   Date
   Jul 6, 2007

                                        [8]Home
                                       [up.gif]
                       [9]Introduction to Principia Cybernetica
                                       [up.gif]
                             [10]Philosophy, Introduction
                                       [up.gif]
                            [11]Epistemology, introduction

                                          Up
                           [12]Prev. [4arrows.gif] [13]Next
                                         Down
     ____________________________________________________________________________
   ____________________________________________________________________________

                                    [14]Discussion
     ____________________________________________________________________________

                                  [15]Add comment...

                                      [space.gif]

References

   1. LYNXIMGMAP:http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/HOMUNCUL.html#PCP-header
   2. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/DUALISM.html
   3. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/DUALISM.html
   4. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/REFCORR.html
   5. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/EVOLCYB.html
   6. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/COPYR.html
   7. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/REFERPCP.html
   8. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/DEFAULT.html
   9. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/INTRO.html
  10. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/PHILOSI.html
  11. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/EPISTEMI.html
  12. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/DUALISM.html
  13. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/METAPHI.html
  14. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/MAKANNOT.html
  15. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/hypercard.acgi$annotform?

[USEMAP]
http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/HOMUNCUL.html#PCP-header
   1. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/DEFAULT.html
   2. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/HOWWEB.html
   3. http://pcp.lanl.gov/HOMUNCUL.html
   4. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/HOMUNCUL.html
   5. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/SERVER.html
   6. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/hypercard.acgi$randomlink?searchstring=.html
   7. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/RECENT.html
   8. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/TOC.html#HOMUNCUL
   9. http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/SEARCH.html